Reality Check: Is NHS funding worse in Wales?

Theresa May saying: If the Labour Party have got all the answers, why is it that we see funding being cut and targets not being met in Wales where the Labour Party is responsible?

The claim: In this week’s Prime Minister’s Questions, Theresa May said health funding in Wales was being cut and targets not being met.

Verdict: There have been cuts in the past, but funding has increased in real terms every year since 2013. Targets are not being met, but neither are they being met in England.

Responding to Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn’s criticism of the government’s handling of winter pressures on the NHS in England, Theresa May attempted to turn the tables.

“If the Labour Party have got all the answers, why is it that we see funding being cut and targets not being met in Wales, where the Labour Party is responsible?” she asked.

Health is a devolved responsibility of the Labour-led Welsh government which, like its counterpart in Westminster, has been criticised over both funding and management.

Between 2009-10 and 2012-13, health spending was cut in real terms by about 3.6% in Wales.

During the same period, the English health budget was increasing, albeit at under 1% a year in real terms, which was less than the average yearly growth of 4% seen under the previous Labour government.

However, since 2012-13, health spending in Wales has increased from £6bn to close to £7bn in 2016-17. The Wales Audit Office notes an average 2.9% annual increase in real terms during this period.

This tops spending increases in England, which have averaged 2% per year since 2013. In fact, Wales now spends £64 more per person on health than England, according to HM Treasury.

Another thing to note is that while the Welsh government is responsible for deciding where money is spent, most of this money is allocated by Westminster.

While the Welsh government had almost £16bn available to spend in 2009-10, this had dropped to about £14.5bn by 2016-17, as allocated by the Barnett formula.

It is indeed up to the Welsh government how it prioritises that money, as Theresa May pointed out.

Missing targets

The prime minister was correct to state that targets are not being met in Wales.

Wales is performing worse than England at hitting the target of admitting, transferring or discharging patients within four hours of arriving in accident and emergency units.

In 2016, England performed better in key diagnosis areas such as hernia, pneumonia and heart disease, while waiting times for important procedures are shorter than in Wales.

Welsh patients have to wait three times as long for hip operations, for example.

But on other key procedures such as heart bypasses and kidney transplants, the waits were shorter. Cancer diagnoses were similar in the two countries.

iframe {
height: 100vh;
}

/* Apply some default styling for core content */
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper html,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper address,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper blockquote,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper body,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dd,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper div,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dl,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dt,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper fieldset,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper form,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper frame,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper frameset,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h1,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h2,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h3,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h4,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h5,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h6,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper noframes,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ol,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper p,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ul,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper center,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dir,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper hr,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper menu,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper pre {
display: block;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper li {
display: list-item;
padding: 0.2em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper head {
display: none;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper table {
display: table;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tr {
display: table-row;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper thead {
display: table-header-group;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tbody {
display: table-row-group;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tfoot {
display: table-footer-group;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper col {
display: table-column;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper colgroup {
display: table-column-group;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper td,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper th {
display: table-cell;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper caption {
display: table-caption;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper th {
font-weight: bolder;
text-align: center;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper caption {
text-align: center;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h1 {
font-size: 2em;
margin: 0.67em 0;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h2 {
font-size: 1.5em;
margin: 0.75em 0;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h3 {
font-size: 1.4em;
margin: 0.83em 0;
margin-top: 2em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h4,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper p,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper blockquote,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ul,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper fieldset,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper form,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ol,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dl,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dir,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper menu {
margin: 1.12em 0;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h5 {
font-size: .83em;
margin: 1.5em 0;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h6 {
font-size: .75em;
margin: 1.67em 0;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h1,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h2,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h3,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h4,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h5,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper h6,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper b,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper strong {
font-weight: bolder;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper blockquote {
margin-left: 2.5em;
margin-right: 2.5em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper i,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper cite,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper em,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper var,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper address {
font-style: italic;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper pre,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tt,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper code,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper kbd,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper samp {
font-family: monospace;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper pre {
white-space: pre;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper button,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper textarea,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper input,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper select {
display: inline-block;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper big {
font-size: 1.17em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper small,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper sub,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper sup {
font-size: 0.83em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper sub {
vertical-align: sub;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper sup {
vertical-align: super;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper table {
border-spacing: 2px;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper thead,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tbody,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tfoot {
vertical-align: middle;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper td,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper th,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper tr {
vertical-align: inherit;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper s,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper strike,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper del {
text-decoration: line-through;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper hr {
border: 1px inset;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ol,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ul,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dir,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper menu,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper dd {
margin-left: 1.12em;
padding-left: 1.12em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ol {
list-style-type: decimal;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ul {
list-style-type: disc;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ol ul,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ul ol,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ul ul,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ol ol {
margin-top: 0;
margin-bottom: 0;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper u,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper ins {
text-decoration: underline;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper center {
text-align: center;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper :link,
.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper :visited {
text-decoration: underline;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper :focus {
outline: thin dotted invert;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper a {
font-size: 1em;
}

.bbc-news-vj-iframe-wrapper iframe {
-webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch; /* Allow scroll when using VoiceOver */
}
]]>

If you can’t see the NHS Tracker, click or tap here.

Read more from Reality Check

Send us your questions

Follow us on Twitter

Reality Check: Is NHS funding worse in Wales?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.